The Great Centrifuge · ch 05
Making Merit Visible
The Transparent: Visible Versus Hidden Merit
All long-term competition is won by those who can best mobilize human capital. True for sport, true for war, and true for companies. I can’t find a single example of a human endeavour where this is not true. But working out who to mobilize is easier in some professions than others.
Leading cyber security teams, I learned it’s easy to identify great hackers. They break in, show what’s broken. If they can’t, they’re not very good. In cyber-attack: Merit is visible.
But cyber defenders? It’s hard. If nothing goes wrong — is that skill, or luck?
You could have experts and still get breached. Or have amateurs and stay safe.
Merit is hidden.
This divide — between professions with visible merit and those with hidden merit — began to deeply haunt me. I see it everywhere.
And in my experience, professions with visible merit do much better over time than professions with hidden merit: The merit compounds, leading to breakthroughs at an exponential, rather than linear pace.
And AI: Both predictive, and Generative, is going to make talent — and character — more transparent, across almost every industry.
The Potential / Outcome Cycle: Voting, Weighing, and the Loop We’re Trying to Close
Benjamin Graham once said,
In the short run, the market is a voting machine but in the long run, it is a weighing machine.
The same is true inside organizations.
In the short term, we reward confidence, visibility, and narrative.
In the long term, we reward delivery, impact, and truth.
Most modern organizational methods — Agile, OKRs, DevOps, SRE, A/B testing — aren’t just about speed.
They’re about alignment, feedback, and most of all, closing the gap between perception and reality.
These management techniques all try to shorten the cycle between perception — how well we think someone will do — which is heavily influence by attributes like charisma — and actual delivery of outcomes — which is influenced a lot more by followership, real talent, and grit.
Between the vote and the weight.
They spin the small centrifuges — our internal talent loops — faster.
Trying to reward the right things sooner.
Trying to make truth visible before it’s too late.
Trying to elevate the people who will succeed.
And now, AI will push this even further. Organizations will link their talent systems to their product and project systems, and AI will be used to determine who really gets things done. Early correlation is a better recipe than late causation.
This will let us see across the horizon. Not just who is performing now, but who is likely to perform well in the long term.
Not just what went wrong — but what will go wrong.
And maybe, most powerfully of all — who is lifting others quietly in the background.
Consider how this transformation is already beginning: AI can now analyze code contributions not just for quantity, but for elegance, maintainability, and how often others build upon it. It can trace the lineage of ideas through meeting transcripts and collaborative documents, identifying who consistently generates concepts that survive to implementation. It can detect patterns in team communications that predict project success months before delivery dates.
Where traditional management might reward the person who speaks most confidently in meetings (voting), AI can connect those statements with eventual outcomes (weighing). Where current systems struggle to recognize the mentor whose quiet guidance prevents failures, AI can correlate decreased error rates with specific advisory relationships. And where today’s organizations often mistake documentation for progress, AI can differentiate between performative work and substantive contribution.
This closing of the perception-reality gap doesn’t just change how we evaluate existing talent — it fundamentally transforms who we can discover in the first place.
Throughout history, our limited ability to see merit across distance, culture, and convention has meant countless brilliant minds remained unrecognized.
AI doesn’t just tighten the cycle between action and recognition; it expands the universe of talent we can identify.
The Forgotten: Lost, Otherworldly Talent
My favorite example of talent our systems almost failed to see comes from a century before our modern organizational methods: the story of Srinivasa Ramanujan. He was born in 1887 in a small town in India. No formal education, just a mind that could somehow see infinite series and number theory in the way most people see traffic lights and furniture.
He sent a letter filled with equations to G.H. Hardy, a famous mathematician at Cambridge. Hardy almost threw it out, but later said discovering him was “the one romantic incident in my life.”.
Ramanujan wasn’t just good — he was otherworldly. He wrote theorems nobody else had seen, often without proof, but with insight so deep that a hundred years later, we’re still unpacking it.
And we almost missed him.
He wasn’t credentialed. He wasn’t networked. He didn’t look like what genius was supposed to look like at the time.
The Measured: China’s Dominance in Weightlifting
Now let’s talk about a very different situation — a pipeline that’s based on sorting not just for talent, but for all the other attributes people require to be truly world-class at any profession.
China dominates Olympic weightlifting — not by accident, but by design.
They identify physical talent early — age six: explosiveness, proportions — the kinds of things that are genetic.
They start training at ten and enter elite programs at sixteen. They’re sorting for dedication, grit, and recovery.
By twenty, another filter is applied: it’s no longer just about lifting weight — it’s about lifting the team. Merit becomes visible. Talent compounds. The team wins: over and over.
When merit is made visible, the extraordinary rise. And the system gets stronger which compounds over time.
Now, let me talk about an industry that has done amazing things, but has never agreed on consistency — where three separate talent sorting mechanisms exist, globally, in parallel: Software Engineering